Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies in the meta-analysis

From: Performance of matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS) in diagnosis of ovarian cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis

 

Author

Year

Region

Age

Sample type

case/control(n=)

Control type

Histological type

Screening method

TP

FP

FN

TN

1

Zheng, Z.G.

2014

China

55

Serum

34/36

Benign

High-grade-serous ovarian cancer

MB-WCX

18

7

16

29

2

Wu, S

2012

China

48.4

Serum

25/30

Health and benign

EOC

MB-WCX

22

5

3

25

3

Swiatly (a)

2017

Poland

65

Serum

11/12

Bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy

OC

C18 ZipTip

8

4

3

8

4

Swiatly (b)

2017

Poland

65

Serum

11/12

Bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy

OC

C18 ZipTip

9

6

2

6

5

Swiatly (c)

2017

Poland

65

Serum

11/12

Bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy

OC

C18 ZipTip

0

6

1

6

6

Periyasamy(a)

2015

India

51

Plasma

39/149

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

MB-HIC C8

33

33

6

116

7

Periyasamy(b)

2015

India

51

Plasma

39/149

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

MB-HIC C8

34

48

5

101

8

Periyasamy(c)

2015

India

51

Plasma

39/149

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

MB-HIC C8

36

58

3

91

9

Periyasamy(d)

2015

India

51

Plasma

39/149

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

MB-WCX

30

32

9

117

10

Periyasamy(e)

2015

India

51

Plasma

39/149

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

MB-WCX

35

45

4

104

11

Periyasamy(f)

2015

India

51

Plasma

39/149

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

MB-WCX

27

38

12

111

12

Periyasamy(g)

2015

India

51

Plasma

24/124

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

IMAC-Cu MBs

19

25

5

99

13

Periyasamy(h)

2015

India

51

Plasma

24/124

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

IMAC-Cu MBs

21

50

3

74

14

Periyasamy(i)

2015

India

51

Plasma

24/124

Health

Serous epithelial ovarian cancer

IMAC-Cu MBs

19

46

5

78

15

John F. (a)

2010

UK

61.8

Serum

39/22

Benign

OC

C18 ZipTip

24

6

15

16

16

John F. (b)

2010

UK

61.8

Serum

39/66

Health

OC

C18 ZipTip

18

7

21

59

17

Lee, J. H.

2016

South Korea

55.5

Serum

29/24

Benign

OC

NA

26

0

3

24

18

Ali Tiss

2010

UK

NA

Serum

23/29

Benign

OC of CA125 > 30 U/mL

C18 ZipTip

16

4

7

25

  1. Abbreviations: EOC Epithelial ovarian cancer, OC Ovarian cancer, MB-WCX Magnetic beads based weak cation exchange, MB-HIC C8 Hydrophobic interaction chromatography magnetic beads C8, IMAC-Cu MBs Cu-immobilized metal affinity chromatography magnetic beads, NA Not available, TP True positive, FP False positive, FN False negative, TN True negative